Hello dear
Welcome to Mama Renie's Pizza of mcarthur
Mama Renie’s Pizza of McArthur is a cozy local gem located at 100 W Main St, Ohio. Known for its fresh, hot, and reasonably priced dishes, this spot shines with standout offerings like thin crust pizzas topped with perfectly seasoned spicy pepperoni, unique creations like the pickle pizza, and flavorful buffalo chicken. Beyond pizza, their crispy fried mushrooms, stacked cheeseburgers, and house-made chips add diversity to the menu. The friendly staff and casual atmosphere make it a welcoming place for families and visitors alike. Despite occasional quiet moments, the quality and taste of the food consistently deliver an authentic and satisfying experience.
Flavors to Try
Experience today’s special creations
Pickle Fries
Decadent Chocolate Spoon Cake
Bbq Chicken
Meat Lovers
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Calzone
$75.00
Philly Cheesesteak
$$5.49Chicken Parmesan
$$4.99Omaha Steak Sub
$$5.99 Discover More
Mama Renie's Pizza of mcarthur
Mama Renie's Pizza of McArthur is a hidden gem nestled in the heart of McArthur, Ohio. Located at 100 W Main St, this cozy eatery blends a down-to-earth vibe with a menu full of hearty, flavorful comfort foods that keep locals and visitors coming back for more. From the moment you step inside or place a takeout order, you can expect warm hospitality paired with dishes crafted to satisfy a variety of cravings.
The pizza here stands out with its thin, crispy crust, balanced sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. The mini cupped spicy pepperoni is a particular highlight, delivering a punch that lingers without overpowering. Unique offerings like the pickle pizza showcase Mama Renie’s flair for inventive flavors that surprise and delight—a testament to their willingness to push boundaries while maintaining homey charm.
Beyond pizza, the menu features an array of appealing choices. The buffalo chicken pizza is a bold, tangy crowd-pleaser, while the fried pickles and fried mushrooms are perfectly crispy starters that set the tone for the meal. Burgers here are stacked high with fresh veggies and paired with fries that shine, especially when dipped in mayo and vinegar—a local favorite twist. Don’t miss the house-made chips, which have earned a reputation as some of the best in the area.
Service at Mama Renie’s is consistently praised for its friendliness and attentiveness, even on busy nights. The atmosphere embodies a casual, dive-bar style with a welcoming, albeit sometimes quiet, vibe. For families, the space feels comfortable though some prefer takeout for convenience and a more relaxed setting. Reasonable prices round out the experience, making it an excellent choice for both budget-conscious diners and those eager to indulge in quality, flavorful fare.
In sum, Mama Renie's Pizza of McArthur delivers a compelling mix of classic and creative dishes set within a genuinely inviting environment. Whether you’re refueling after outdoor adventures like hiking in Hocking Hills or simply seeking a reliable spot for pizza and more, this local favorite is more than worth the visit.
Stories & Reviews
Guestbook
“ A cute dive bar-esque joint. We came on a Thursday night and they were super busy! Even though they were, our service never slowed. We started with an order of fried mushrooms, and for our mains we got a burger and fries and a chicken strip basket. Our food was hot, fresh, and reasonably priced. I would definitely go again. The only thing that would make this place top notch was if they made their own ranch. That’s just the Michigander in me loving ranch lol. ”
“ We are visiting from out of town and was craving pizza. This pizza came through with flying colors! Amazing thin crust, perfect tasting sauce, the exact right amount of cheese, and the most amazing mini cupped kind of spicy pepperoni. Absolutely fantastic! Atmosphere while picking up was great and the young lady who helped us was such a delight. Would and most definitely WILL be eating here again. ”
“ We stopped at Mama Renies after a long day of hiking at Moonville and it was great. Had two kids with us, wasn't at all a problem. The pizza was awesome, really enjoyed the buffalo chicken. Prices are very reasonable. All in all a really excellent little pizza and tavern right in the heart of McArthur. ”
“ Very good food, and the people are normally very friendly! Don’t love the atmosphere with the kids, and sometimes it smells kinda bad inside. Just order take out and it’s always delicious. ”
“ Visiting the area for Hocking hills. Passed this place on the way in and made sure to try them before we left. Glad we did! Very friendly and fun crew. Delicious food. Partner saw the Pickle Pizza. Now listen , sounds weird but if you love pickles. You'll love this. Best pickle pizza I've ever had . Also very reasonably priced. Partner had the peanut butter pie and I had a slice of peach. ”